You can find out more about here Rev. Karen Acres Funeral Celebrant
Direct Cremation: “I Don’t Want a Fuss.” But What About Those Left Behind?
A MoneyTrainers podcast with Richard Smith and Karen Acres, Minister and Funeral Celebrant
“I don’t want a fuss. Just get rid of me as cheaply as possible.”
Sound familiar?
It’s something many of us say when the subject of our funeral comes up.
No expensive coffin. No flowers. No big service. No family gathering that costs a small fortune.
Fair enough. Nobody wants their family spending thousands of pounds they haven’t got.
But there’s a question we often forget to ask.
Is the funeral just about what we want, or should we also think about what the people left behind might need?
That’s what I discussed with Karen Acres, a minister and funeral celebrant who has spent years helping families say goodbye to people they love.
And Karen has some strong views.
Not because she wants everyone to have a traditional funeral, but because she’s seen what can happen when families don’t fully understand the choices they’ve made.
Direct Cremation. Cheap, Simple, Job Done?
Direct cremation has become a popular choice.
The idea is simple. When you die, your body is collected and cremated without an attended funeral service. Your ashes are then returned to your family, or dealt with according to the arrangements made.
No service at the crematorium. No mourners. No ceremony.
You can still have a memorial or family gathering later, of course.
For some people, that’s exactly what they want. And there’s nothing wrong with it.
But here’s where Karen raised an important point.
Do families really understand what they are buying?
Some assume they will be able to see their loved one before the cremation. Others expect to know when and where the cremation will take place.
Some want a few quiet minutes to say goodbye.
Not every direct cremation provider offers those options.
Karen has spoken to families who were upset to discover that the arrangements were not what they had expected.
That doesn’t mean all direct cremation firms provide a poor service. Far from it.
It means you need to ask questions before signing up.
And not just, “How much?”
What If You Never Got to Say Goodbye?
Imagine your mum dies while you’re travelling home to see her.
Or your husband dies suddenly, without warning.
Or a relative lives overseas and simply cannot get back in time.
For some families, being able to see the person after death matters a great deal.
Karen described how much comfort people can take from spending a little time with someone who has died.
Perhaps playing their favourite music. Saying a prayer. Holding their hand. Or simply sitting quietly.
No grand ceremony. No fuss.
Just a chance to say goodbye.
That opportunity may not be available with the cheapest direct cremation package.
And once the cremation has taken place, there’s no going back.
Something worth thinking about before you tell your family to choose the cheapest option.
What Does a Funeral Celebrant Actually Do?
I’ll admit that many people probably don’t understand how much work goes into a funeral service.
Karen explained what happens behind the scenes.
She meets the family. She listens to stories about the person who has died. She learns about their life, their habits, their humour and the things that made them who they were.
Sometimes there’s laughter. Sometimes there are tears. Usually there’s a bit of both.
She then puts together a service that reflects that person.
Not a standard script with a name changed at the top.
A proper account of someone’s life, with readings, music and memories chosen by the family.
She also helps them work through the practical arrangements with the funeral director.
For a family dealing with a death, having someone who knows what they’re doing can make a real difference.
Of course, not everybody wants that sort of service.
But it’s worth knowing what you’re choosing to miss.
Does a Funeral Really Have to Cost Thousands?
Here’s something else we discussed.
Why do people sometimes assume there are only two choices?
An expensive funeral costing thousands of pounds, or a cheap direct cremation with nobody present.
Surely there’s something in between?
Karen thinks so.
During the podcast, she described contacting funeral directors to find an affordable funeral for a family with very little money.
The lowest quote she received was around £2,100, including a short attended farewell at the crematorium.
That’s not a guaranteed price, and costs will vary depending on where you live and what you need.
But it shows why it’s worth asking.
What if you only want six people there?
What if you don’t want expensive flowers, a procession of cars or a lengthy service?
What if all you want is 20 minutes to say goodbye?
Ask the funeral director what they can offer within your budget.
You might be surprised.
And if money is tight, say so at the start.
There’s no shame in that.
And Who Says You Have to Pay for a Wake?
Here’s another expense that can get out of hand.
The wake.
Some people feel they have to arrange a venue, provide food, buy drinks and invite half the town.
Why?
If that’s what the family wants, and they can afford it, fine.
But there’s no rule that says you have to spend hundreds or thousands of pounds feeding people after a funeral.
Karen made the point that a cup of tea, a few sandwiches and a chat at home might be all a family needs.
Sometimes a small gathering is far more personal.
A funeral isn’t a competition to see who can spend the most money.
And nobody should feel guilty because they cannot afford a big send-off.
Seven Questions to Ask Before Choosing Direct Cremation
If you or someone in your family is considering direct cremation, here’s a useful checklist.
- Where will the person be taken? Ask where and how they will be cared for before cremation.
- Can the family visit? Is there an option to see the person or spend a few minutes saying goodbye?
- Where will the cremation take place? Will it be local or somewhere else?
- Will anyone tell us when it happens? Some providers do not give families an exact date in advance.
- What happens to the ashes? How and when will they be returned, and does that cost extra?
- What’s included in the price? Check for additional charges and ask for the full cost in writing.
- Is there a simple attended option? Compare the price before making your choice.
None of these questions is difficult.
But trying to get answers after someone has died can be a very different matter.
“I Don’t Want a Fuss” Isn’t Really a Funeral Plan
This is where the podcast connects with my work on The Last Ten Years.
I spend a lot of time encouraging people to think about what will happen as they grow older, lose the ability to make decisions or eventually die.
We talk about wills, powers of attorney, care, money and medical wishes.
But funeral arrangements are part of that conversation too.
I’ve heard plenty of people say:
“Just put me in a cardboard box.”
“Don’t waste money on flowers.”
“I don’t want anyone standing around crying.”
All perfectly reasonable wishes.
But have you spoken to your partner, children or other people who might have to make those arrangements?
What if your daughter wants a short service?
What if your husband would find comfort in seeing you one last time?
What if your family wants to get together, tell a few stories and remember you?
Your wishes matter. But so do the needs of the people who will have to live with those decisions.
It’s worth having that conversation now.
Not when somebody is sitting across a desk from a funeral director, trying to make decisions while dealing with a death.
My Thoughts After Talking to Karen
I’m not against direct cremation.
For some families, it makes good sense. It’s affordable, straightforward and avoids much of the cost of a traditional funeral.
But there’s a difference between making an informed choice and choosing something because it’s cheap.
Karen’s point is simple.
Don’t assume that no funeral means no grief, no upset or no need to say goodbye.
And don’t assume that an attended funeral must cost a fortune.
Find out what’s available. Ask the questions. Talk to your family.
Above all, don’t leave people guessing what you meant by “I don’t want a fuss”.
Because doing nothing is still a decision.
And somebody else may have to deal with the consequences.
Listen to the Podcast
Direct Cremation and the Importance of Saying Goodbye, with Karen Acres
In this episode, Karen and I discuss direct cremation, funeral costs, what a celebrant does and why a simple goodbye can matter so much.
We also look at ways to keep funeral costs down, whether you really need a wake and the questions families should ask before making arrangements.
It’s a frank conversation about something that will affect every family sooner or later.
Listen to the full conversation with Karen Acres and Richard Smith.
For more help with later-life planning, family decisions, wills, powers of attorney and preparing for the years ahead, visit The Last Ten Years.
Note: The £2,100 funeral cost mentioned in the podcast was an example discussed during the recording. Prices and services vary. Always ask providers for an up-to-date written quote.
Richard Smith
MoneyTrainers | The Last Ten Years
Helping people understand money, later life and the decisions nobody wants to talk about until they have to.
Get in touch
Podcast: Play in new window | Download (28.4MB)